|First Appearance||Perils of Paranoia|
Mike testified that he was with a friend who was accused of robbery watching a New Jersey Devils hockey game at his home when the robbery was taking place. When he was being cross-examined by Tommy, he reiterated that long time Devils goaltender Martin Brodeur was in goal. Tommy even showed him a copy of a newspaper report showing Brodeur in goal. However, Tommy showed Mike the next day's paper, which noted that they had misidentified the Devils' backup goaltender Johan Hedberg as Brodeur, breaking the alibi.