Wikia

House Wiki

Gregory House and Sherlock Holmes connections

Talk7
5,217pages on
this wiki
Paget holmes

Holmes and Watson.

'How often have I said to you that when you have eliminated the impossible, whatever remains, however improbable, must be the truth?' - Sherlock Holmes in The Sign of the Four (1890) on the basic concept behind the differential diagnosis.

Series creator David Shore has said in an interview that Gregory House's character is partly inspired by Sherlock Holmes.[1] The name "House" is a play on "Holmes" (with English pronunciation, a homophone for "homes").[2][3]

The "Uncle Jeremy's Household", published in "Boy's Own Paper" magazine is considered the first sketch that has clear raw material relating to Sherlockian stories, including notably Baker Street, a Watson-like narrator, a strong-willed woman looking ahead to Irene Adler and a prototype of Holmes, whose early name was Hugh Lawrence.

Both Holmes and House are experts who are brought into cases that have proven too difficult for other investigators. Both characters exhibit remarkable powers of observation and deduction, a tendency to come to rapid conclusions after the briefest examination of the circumstances, drug use (cocaine for Holmes, Vicodin for House, morphine for both), talent with a musical instrument (violin for Holmes, piano, guitar and harmonica for House), and only one real friend (Dr. Watson and Dr. Wilson, respectively), who connects the detached hero to human concerns. Also, just like Watson, at one point Wilson is roommates with House. Watson and Wilson are both attributed to be "ladies' men"; Watson has at least two wives over the course of Holmes' run in literature, while Dr. Wilson has three ex-wives. House also limps and requires the use of a cane due to an infarction that occurred in his leg, an allusion to Watson's limp from an old war wound. Holmes and House also share an unconventional personality and, to an extent, a brusqueness of manner, especially when occupied in an interesting case. Actor Hugh Laurie has remarked that House's obsession with television, video games, and popular music is meant to echo Holmes' habit of listening to classical music or reading dull monographs for hours on end in order to relax his mind while pondering a case.

While House uses large quantities of Vicodin for pain management, Holmes used drugs in an experimental, often research-driven modality, and also took cocaine intravenously when bored; some episodes imply that House at one time also used drugs in this experimental fashion before he developed his current dependency on Vicodin, making references to experiences with LSD and cocaine. In the episode "Distractions", House used LSD to treat a self-induced migraine.

In addition, during the series Bonnie Wilson complained that Wilson's allegiance to House often meant Wilson didn't have time for her. The Holmes stories also have several instances where one of Watson's wives was put out when Watson dropped everything to join Holmes on an adventure. The first Sherlock Holmes movie with Robert Downey Jr. and the new British series Sherlock also show the strain that the relationship between the two men has on Watson's relationships with women.

One other important detail on House's and Holmes' drug use, is the ways Wilson/Watson handles their friends drug use. Medically they have no problem while they abuse narcotics, but morally, is a different story; they both disagree with their friends vices. But while Watson has claimed to have "weaned" Holmes off cocaine, Wilson has several times attempted to rid House of his Vicodin addiction.

House and wilson

House and Wilson.

House's dependency on Vicodin as a substitute to his cases has recently been touched upon at the onset of Season Three. Without the intellectual stimulation of diagnosing patients, House falls into a stark depression, even when his leg is supposedly "cured" and pain-free (see the episode "No Reason"). He requires either the high of a confirmed diagnosis or Vicodin to function. The similarity between his and Holmes' own addictions (Holmes only required drugs whenever there wasn't a case at hand) is another bridge between them.

The patient in the series' pilot episode is named Rebecca Adler, whereas Holmes is outwitted by Irene Adler in his first short story, "A Scandal in Bohemia". The man who shoots House in the episode "No Reason" has the surname Moriarty, echoing Holmes' nemesis Professor Moriarty (the name is never mentioned in the episode; merely derived from the credits. Also, it is mentioned in the executive producer commentary of the episode on the DVD.). Also, in one episode, House's apartment number is revealed to be 221B, Sherlock Holmes' Baker Street address. In the episode "Whac-A-Mole", House challenges his team to a game, and places what he says is the right answer in an envelope on which was written "The game is a itchy foot," which is a play on "The game is afoot," a quote often attributed to Holmes (who was in turn quoting Shakespeare (Henry IV, part 1)).

Near the end of the episode "Failure to Communicate," in explaining his understanding of what his patient with aphasia is actually saying, House gives a relatively common riddle about a room with an all-southern view and a polar bear to his lackeys. This is exactly the same riddle given by Holmes to Dr. Watson in Young Sherlock Holmes, and another nod to the parallels between Holmes and House.

The character of Sherlock Holmes was originally based by his creator, Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, on Joseph Bell, a doctor noted for his love of deductive reasoning and skill with both ordinary diagnostics and forensic medicine (which was quite new at the time); the character of House can thus be seen in a way as taking the idea of Sherlock Holmes full circle.

In "It's a Wonderful Lie", House receives a second-edition Arthur Conan Doyle as one of his Secret Santa gifts.

In chapter 5x11, "Joy to the World", Wilson refers to an "Irene Adler" (calling her House's one true love) when he is talking with Taub and Kutner about why he threw away a valuable gift (that valuable gift being a rare medical text on diagnosis written by a "Dr. Joseph Bell"), . "Irene Adler" is the antagonist of the Sherlock Holmes short story "A Scandal in Bohemia" and actually manages to outwit Holmes.

In chapter 7x13, "Two Stories", we get to see Dr. House's drivers license, with his Baker Street address on it.

One of the guest stars in episode 3x18 "Airborne", Jenny O'Hara appeared in the television movie The Return of the World's Greatest Detective as "Dr. Joan Watson", treating a patient (Larry Hagman) who believes he is Sherlock Holmes.

There is also an unintentional degree of connection to character of Sherlock Holmes to the House series via Hugh Laurie's series "Fortysomething". "Fortysomething" is a 2003 UK television series, starring and directed by Hugh Laurie as Paul Slippery, a doctor facing a mid-life crisis. Hugh's character has three sons, one of whom is played by Benedict Cumberbatch. Cumberbatch is currently the new present-day Sherlock Holmes on BBC's series "SHERLOCK" [1].

The Biography episode on Sherlock Holmes was hosted by Peter Graves.

ElementaryEdit

Several House alumni have appeared on the CBS series "Elementary"

ReferencesEdit

  1. Zap2it - TV news - Building 'House' Is Hard Work
  2. Wittler, Wendell. "Living in a ‘House’ built for one", MSNBC, April 18, 2005.
  3. "David Shore", In Camera, October issue.

Further readingEdit


Gregory House at Wikipedia

Around Wikia's network

Random Wiki